Snippet Name: SQL_Server_to_MySQL_Conversion
Tags:
Created Date: 2025-06-16 13:12:47
Last Modified Date: 2025-05-31 10:32:12
Dependencies:
DBA Notes:
Sample Output:
Title: SQL Server to MySQL Conversion
Author: user
help me convert a SLQ Server Table Definition into the MySQL Equivalent: CREATE TABLE [dbo].[GEOPLANET] (
[GEOPLANETID] INT IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL,
[ORBITALORDER] INT NULL,
[PLANETNAME] VARCHAR(30) NULL,
[PLANETTYPE] VARCHAR(30) NULL,
CONSTRAINT [PK__GEOPLANET__CLUSTERED] PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (GEOPLANETID))
Author: ChatGPT
Here's the equivalent MySQL table definition for the SQL Server table `GEOPLANET`:
```sql
CREATE TABLE GEOPLANET (
GEOPLANETID INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
ORBITALORDER INT NULL,
PLANETNAME VARCHAR(30) NULL,
PLANETTYPE VARCHAR(30) NULL,
PRIMARY KEY (GEOPLANETID)
);
```
### Key differences explained:
1. **AUTO_INCREMENT**:
- MySQL uses `AUTO_INCREMENT` for auto-incrementing primary keys instead of `IDENTITY`.
2. **Clustered Index**:
- In MySQL, the primary key is automatically a clustered index. There's no need to specify `PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED`.
3. **Schema Specification**:
- MySQL doesn't use the `[dbo]` schema prefix.
4. **Brackets vs Backticks**:
- MySQL uses backticks (`) for identifiers if needed (not mandatory unless there are special characters or reserved words).
Let me know if you need further adjustments or have additional constraints!
Author: user
and this oen as well, that has some constraints? CREATE TABLE [dbo].[GEOMOON] (
[GEOMOONID] INT IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL,
[GEOPLANETID] INT NULL,
[ORBITALORDER] INT NULL,
[MOONNAME] VARCHAR(30) NULL,
[MOONTYPE] VARCHAR(30) NULL,
CONSTRAINT [PK__GEOMOON__CLUSTERED] PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (GEOMOONID),
CONSTRAINT [FK__GEOMOON__GEOPLAN__09DE7BCC] FOREIGN KEY (GEOPLANETID) REFERENCES GEOPLANET(GEOPLANETID))
Author: ChatGPT
Here???s the MySQL equivalent for the `GEOMOON` table, including the constraints:
```sql
CREATE TABLE GEOMOON (
GEOMOONID INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
GEOPLANETID INT NULL,
ORBITALORDER INT NULL,
MOONNAME VARCHAR(30) NULL,
MOONTYPE VARCHAR(30) NULL,
PRIMARY KEY (GEOMOONID),
CONSTRAINT FK_GEOMOON_GEOPLANET FOREIGN KEY (GEOPLANETID) REFERENCES GEOPLANET(GEOPLANETID)
);
```
### Key Differences Explained:
1. **AUTO_INCREMENT**:
- Replaces `IDENTITY(1,1)` for the `GEOMOONID` column.
2. **Clustered Primary Key**:
- MySQL automatically makes the primary key clustered; no need for explicit `CLUSTERED`.
3. **Foreign Key Naming**:
- MySQL allows custom names for foreign keys. `FK_GEOMOON_GEOPLANET` is used instead of the SQL Server-style generated name `[FK__GEOMOON__GEOPLAN__09DE7BCC]`.
4. **Schema Prefix (`[dbo]`)**:
- MySQL doesn???t use schema prefixes.
5. **Bracket Replacement**:
- MySQL uses backticks (or nothing) instead of brackets around identifiers.
This table definition will work seamlessly in MySQL while maintaining the constraints from the SQL Server version. Let me know if you have any specific needs or additional requirements!
Author: user
how can i modify this to support compression?CREATE TABLE `GEOPLANET` (
`GEOPLANETID` INT AUTO_INCREMENT NOT NULL,
`ORBITALORDER` INT NULL,
`PLANETNAME` VARCHAR(30) NULL,
`PLANETTYPE` VARCHAR(30) NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK__GEOPLANET__CLUSTERED` PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (`GEOPLANETID` asc) WITH (DATA_COMPRESSION = PAGE ));
Author: ChatGPT
MySQL does not have a direct `WITH (DATA_COMPRESSION = PAGE)` clause like SQL Server. However, you can enable compression in MySQL by using **InnoDB table compression** or **ROW_FORMAT** settings. Below is an example of how to modify the `GEOPLANET` table to support compression in MySQL:
### Using InnoDB Table Compression:
```sql
CREATE TABLE `GEOPLANET` (
`GEOPLANETID` INT AUTO_INCREMENT NOT NULL,
`ORBITALORDER` INT NULL,
`PLANETNAME` VARCHAR(30) NULL,
`PLANETTYPE` VARCHAR(30) NULL,
PRIMARY KEY (`GEOPLANETID`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED KEY_BLOCK_SIZE=8;
```
### Explanation:
1. **`ENGINE=InnoDB`**:
- Specifies the storage engine. InnoDB supports compression.
2. **`ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED`**:
- Enables table compression for the `GEOPLANET` table.
3. **`KEY_BLOCK_SIZE=8`**:
- Optionally sets the size (in KB) for InnoDB compressed blocks. Valid values are typically 1, 2, 4, 8, or 16 depending on the page size.
### Notes:
- To use `ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED`, your MySQL server must support InnoDB compression (check the documentation for your MySQL version).
- Compression works best for tables with large amounts of repetitive data.
- If you're using MySQL 8.0, consider that newer versions deprecate `ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED` in favor of more efficient compression methods.
Let me know if you'd like to explore alternative methods or need assistance implementing this!
Author: user
so is mysql 8 automatically compressing data, where SQL server still has it as optional
Author: ChatGPT
Yes, **MySQL 8.0** and **SQL Server** have different approaches to data compression:
### **MySQL 8.0 Compression**
- **InnoDB Transparent Page Compression**:
- Starting with MySQL 8.0, compression is handled at the storage layer with **Transparent Page Compression**, which integrates with the filesystem.
- It reduces storage space automatically when supported by the storage hardware or the underlying file system (e.g., `zlib` or `lz4` compression).
- You don???t have to specify compression settings explicitly unless using legacy `ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED`, which is still supported but deprecated in MySQL 8.0.
- **Benefit**: Compression is more integrated and efficient compared to earlier MySQL versions.
### **SQL Server Compression**
- SQL Server offers **data compression** as an optional feature, allowing you to choose from:
- **ROW Compression**: Reduces storage by optimizing metadata (e.g., smaller data types for fixed-length fields).
- **PAGE Compression**: Combines row compression with additional compression methods such as prefix and dictionary compression.
- Compression is explicitly specified during table creation or added later using `ALTER TABLE` commands.
- SQL Server's approach gives you more granular control over compression but requires manual configuration.
### **Key Differences**
| Feature | MySQL 8.0 | SQL Server |
|--------------------------------|-------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
| Compression Approach | Transparent, hardware-integrated | Optional, user-configurable |
| Default Behavior | Transparent compression (if supported) | No compression unless configured |
| Fine-Grained Control | Limited (legacy methods deprecated) | Extensive (ROW, PAGE compression) |
| Storage Efficiency | Improved with transparent compression | Configurable and highly tunable |
### **Takeaway**
- In MySQL 8.0, compression is more **transparent and automatic**, focusing on ease of use and filesystem integration.
- In SQL Server, compression is a **manual, fine-grained optimization**, providing detailed control over resource usage and performance.
If your goal is to optimize storage and performance, SQL Server may require explicit configuration for compression, whereas MySQL 8.0 simplifies the process by leveraging its built-in mechanisms. Let me know if you???d like more details on enabling SQL Server compression or MySQL???s transparent page compression!
Author: user
can you help me convert this view definition? i know i need to use CONCAT, but the logic to add preceeding zeros to some of the values, adn hten concatenate elides me:
CREATE VIEW vwGeoCity
AS
SELECT RIGHT('00' + CONVERT(VARCHAR,citz.GeoStateID),2 )
+ RIGHT('000' +CONVERT(VARCHAR,citz.GEOCOUNTYID),3) AS CountyCode,
RIGHT('00' + CONVERT(VARCHAR,citz.GeoStateID),2 )GeoStateCode,
RIGHT('000' +CONVERT(VARCHAR,citz.GEOCOUNTYID),3) GeoCountyCode,
citz.[CITYNAME],
REPLACE(REPLACE(REPLACE(COUNTYNAME,' County',''),' Borough',''),' Census Area','') AS CountyName,
stz.[FIPSNAME]
FROM [dbo].[GEOCITY] citz
INNER JOIN [dbo].[GEOCOUNTY] cntyz ON [cntyz].[GEOSTATEID] = [citz].[GEOSTATEID] AND [cntyz].[GEOCOUNTYID] = [citz].[GEOCOUNTYID]
INNER JOIN [dbo].[GEOSTATE] stz ON [stz].[GEOSTATEID] = [citz].[GEOSTATEID]
GO
Author: ChatGPT
Here???s how you can convert the given SQL Server `vwGeoCity` view definition to MySQL, using `CONCAT` and `LPAD` to handle the logic for adding preceding zeros:
```sql
CREATE VIEW vwGeoCity AS
SELECT
CONCAT(LPAD(citz.GeoStateID, 2, '0'), LPAD(citz.GEOCOUNTYID, 3, '0')) AS CountyCode,
LPAD(citz.GeoStateID, 2, '0') AS GeoStateCode,
LPAD(citz.GEOCOUNTYID, 3, '0') AS GeoCountyCode,
citz.CITYNAME,
REPLACE(REPLACE(REPLACE(cntyz.COUNTYNAME, ' County', ''), ' Borough', ''), ' Census Area', '') AS CountyName,
stz.FIPSNAME
FROM GEOCITY citz
INNER JOIN GEOCOUNTY cntyz
ON cntyz.GEOSTATEID = citz.GEOSTATEID
AND cntyz.GEOCOUNTYID = citz.GEOCOUNTYID
INNER JOIN GEOSTATE stz
ON stz.GEOSTATEID = citz.GEOSTATEID;
```
### Explanation:
1. **`LPAD` for Preceding Zeros**:
- `LPAD(value, length, '0')` is used to pad values with leading zeros. This replaces `RIGHT('00' + ...)` logic in SQL Server.
- For example:
- `LPAD(citz.GeoStateID, 2, '0')` ensures `GeoStateID` is at least 2 characters long, padded with leading zeros if necessary.
- `LPAD(citz.GEOCOUNTYID, 3, '0')` does the same for `GEOCOUNTYID`.
2. **`CONCAT` for String Concatenation**:
- `CONCAT` replaces the `+` operator used for string concatenation in SQL Server.
3. **`REPLACE` Function**:
- Works similarly in MySQL to remove specific substrings (e.g., `' County'`, `' Borough'`, `' Census Area'`).
4. **Table and Column Case Sensitivity**:
- MySQL may require exact case matches for table and column names. Ensure that `GEOCITY`, `GEOCOUNTY`, and `GEOSTATE` tables match your MySQL schema in case.
5. **Removal of `GO`**:
- `GO` is a batch separator in SQL Server. It???s not used in MySQL.
Let me know if you encounter issues or need further clarification!
Author: user
on this same theme, i have a table in SQL server that has a primary key on a nvarchar(200)_ column, but in converting to mysql sytax, i get an
Error Code: 1071. Specified key was too long; max key length is 767 bytes; do you have a suggestion on how to handle that error? this was the table definition as converted: -- CREATE SCHEMA IF NOT EXISTS `dbo`;
-- USE `dbo`;
DROP TABLE IF EXISTS `AppSetting`;
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `AppSetting` (
`Key` varchar(200) CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
`Value` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
`Description` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK_AppSetting` PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (`Key` asc) )
ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci
ROW_FORMAT=COMPACT;
Author: ChatGPT
The error arises because MySQL imposes a limit on the maximum key length for an index, which is **767 bytes** for the default InnoDB row format (`COMPACT` or `REDUNDANT`). With `utf8mb4`, each character can use up to **4 bytes**, meaning a `VARCHAR(200)` column could require up to **800 bytes**, exceeding the limit.
### Solutions to Address the Issue
#### 1. Reduce the Key Column Length
If the `Key` column can be reasonably shortened, reduce its length to fit within the 767-byte limit:
```sql
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `AppSetting` (
`Key` VARCHAR(191) CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
`Value` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
`Description` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK_AppSetting` PRIMARY KEY (`Key`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci ROW_FORMAT=COMPACT;
```
- **Why `191`?**: With `utf8mb4`, `191 characters * 4 bytes = 764 bytes`, which fits under the limit.
---
#### 2. Use a Hash-Based Key
If reducing the column length isn't feasible, you can use a hash of the `Key` column for the primary key:
```sql
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `AppSetting` (
`Key` VARCHAR(200) CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
`KeyHash` BINARY(32) GENERATED ALWAYS AS (UNHEX(SHA2(`Key`, 256))) STORED NOT NULL,
`Value` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
`Description` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK_AppSetting` PRIMARY KEY (`KeyHash`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci ROW_FORMAT=COMPACT;
```
- **Explanation**:
- A new column `KeyHash` stores the hash of `Key` (256-bit SHA-2 hash, which is 32 bytes).
- `KeyHash` serves as the primary key, solving the length issue.
- MySQL automatically generates the hash value whenever the `Key` column is updated.
---
#### 3. Use a Different Row Format
Switch to the `DYNAMIC` or `COMPRESSED` row format in InnoDB, which supports longer key lengths (up to **3072 bytes** with MySQL 5.7+):
```sql
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `AppSetting` (
`Key` VARCHAR(200) CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
`Value` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
`Description` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK_AppSetting` PRIMARY KEY (`Key`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci ROW_FORMAT=DYNAMIC;
```
- **Note**: Ensure your MySQL version and configuration (`innodb_file_format`) support this row format.
---
#### 4. Use a Separate Surrogate Key
Introduce an auto-incrementing integer column as the primary key and use the `Key` column as a unique constraint:
```sql
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `AppSetting` (
`ID` INT AUTO_INCREMENT NOT NULL,
`Key` VARCHAR(200) CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NOT NULL,
`Value` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
`Description` TEXT CHARACTER SET utf8mb4 COLLATE utf8mb4_unicode_ci NULL,
CONSTRAINT `PK_AppSetting` PRIMARY KEY (`ID`),
UNIQUE KEY `UQ_Key` (`Key`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8mb4 COLLATE=utf8mb4_unicode_ci ROW_FORMAT=COMPACT;
```
- **Advantages**:
- Avoids key length issues entirely.
- Allows for more efficient joins and indexing in many cases.
---
### Recommended Solution
- If the column length can be reduced, **option 1** is the simplest.
- If reducing the column length isn't possible, and a hash-based approach is acceptable, **option 2** provides a robust workaround.
- For compatibility and future-proofing, **option 3** is worth considering if supported by your MySQL version.
- Use **option 4** if you're open to adding a surrogate key.
Let me know which approach you'd like to implement!